In Frankfurt, Annette and I are members of a group of wine and food aficiniados that meets about once a month in a top restaurant. In August, we had dinner at Weinsinn.
There were six of us. We had 7 bottles of wine. We all had 4 courses. We spent Euro 175 including tax and tip per person.
See also:
Lunch and Beaujolais at Weinsinn in Frankfurt am Main, Germany
Sauvignon Blanc in Austria – A Comparative Tasting with Falstaff's Peter Moser at Weinsinn in Frankfurt, Germany
Weinsinn
New York Times
By PETE WELLS - October 22, 2013: When young lovers dream of a romantic European dinner in a back-street hideaway packed with locals, those back streets tend to be in Paris or Florence, not Düsseldorf or Nuremberg. When thrill-seeking diners book long-distance travel to taste some pathbreaking chef’s strange new inventions, their planes land in places like Barcelona or Copenhagen, not Leipzig or Dresden.
Although the 2013 Michelin Guide paid lavish attention to Germany, awarding 3 stars to 10 restaurants there, neither those restaurants nor their chefs are household names in any country but their own. When Germany flexes its economic muscle, other countries jump to attention. When it shows off its gastronomic power, they shrug.
Anytime the world seems to have made a secret pact to ignore a subject, curious minds grow even more curious. So off I went last month on a brief but industrious eating tour of Germany. I traveled to three of the cities foreigners are most likely to visit, Munich, Frankfurt and Berlin, making reservations in relatively new restaurants. None of them were especially luxurious or expensive compared with the rarefied dining rooms that are catnip to the Michelin Guide.
German chefs tend to play a long game, honing their craft in the same kitchen for decades. Coming from New York, where chefs will put a restaurant on their résumés after working there free for a few weeks, I was deeply impressed by the German dedication to putting down roots. But I was especially interested in seeing where the country’s restaurant scene may be going next, so I restricted myself to places that had opened since the start of this decade.
Around the same time, my colleague Frank Bruni was pursuing a similar assignment in China, following similar rules. Unlike me, he stuck to the rules. I bent them to write about a very good meal I had in Frankfurt at Weinsinn, which opened at the end of 2009. My rationale: In its first months, Weinsinn was a wine bar, and didn’t begin to evolve into a restaurant until it hired its current chef, André Rickert, the following year.
Mr. Rickert has a modernist’s skill set and a modernist’s talent for combining the serious and the playful. Look what he does to ratatouille. Even its fans have to admit that the dish, a lump of stewed vegetables mired in a tar pit of olive oil, is usually no great beauty. Mr. Rickert’s version is a colorful, bright, edible garden, a field of couscous across which he plants black olives, shards of feta, a bright green mound of basil ice cream and warm cherry tomatoes that dissolved into sweet pulp on my tongue like berries in a pie.
The ingredients were strewn all across the plate, but the flavors were firmly rooted. That was the case, too, with a dessert of late-summer damson plums that appeared in three guises: stuffed into a tender dumpling, frozen into sorbet and poached with cinnamon syrup.
Weinsinn is compact, with only 35 seats in two small dining rooms. So is Mr. Rickert’s menu of three appetizers, three main courses and three desserts. The wine list, on the other hand, goes on for page after page, although there is a simpler way. We asked the sommelier, Jens Gabelmann, to choose for us. He sized up our table at a glance and brought us just the wine we might have asked for if we had been able to put our wishes into words.
Weinsinn is perpetually full but not a scene; all the action is on the plates and in the glasses. The owners, Matthias Scheiber and Milica Trajkovska, his wife, say they borrowed the idea of serving serious food and drink for reasonable prices in a lively, informal room from French places like La Régalade.
“The bistronomy movement does not exist in Germany,” Mr. Scheiber said. Traditionally, he continued, restaurant cooking in his country isn’t taken seriously unless it “comes out of hotels” with highly formal dining rooms.
Michelin (1 Star)
Kein Wunder, dass diese Adresse so gefragt ist: Hier geht es lebhaft zu, stimmig die moderne Einrichtung, wirklich toll die ausdrucksstarke und angenehm geradlinige Küche! Und dazu gibt es über 200 Positionen Wein.
Gault Millau (16 Points)
Im Weinsinn findet man schnell zum Leichtsinn. Lockere Atmosphäre, unkomplizierter Service, beherzte Küche und gute Weinkarte wirken nun mal animierend – entsprechend lebhaft ist der Gästezuspruch für André Rickerts roten Gazpacho mit Flusskrebs oder seine Interpretation der thailändischen Tom Kha Gai-Suppe per Kabeljau im Limettensud mit Kokos. Völlig stimmig auch der roh marinierte Cobia-Barsch mit…
Culinary Insights
...And Germany? There seems to be some hope for food enthusiasts looking for a excellent fare at reasonable prices as two Amador disciples have begun to cook in a neo-bistro manner, André Rickert at Weinsinn in Frankfurt and Christoph Kubenz at Schaumahl in Offenburg (where no Frankfurter would normally set a step, but it’s worth it). But, and that is gratifying, they are not pure copyists of the French, but very distinct and unique protagonists of a maybe developing German bistronomic scene… Let’s see how Rickert is doing lately at Weinsinn…
André Rickert has undergone his initial apprenticeship at Thomas Bühner when the latter was still cooking in Dortmund. In the following years he became an Amador disciple, lately being part of Caro Baum’s team at the formidable Amesa in Mannheim. His cooking or better plating clearly speaks the Amador ‘language’ in that dishes are plated in a modern, precise and transparent manner to let the main product be in focus whereas all other ingredients are perfectly proportioned and balanced. Clearly, in a bistro-style ambiance like Weinsinn one cannot serve cutting high-end dishes like at Amador or Amesa but he comprises only to some extent and most visitors are pleasantly surprised to see such a modern cuisine in a wine bar...
Dinner
3 Gänge € 65 / 4 Gänge € 75 / 5 Gänge € 85 / 6 Gänge € 95
3 course € 65 / 4 course € 75 / 5 course € 85 / 6 course € 95
Greetings from the Chef
Vorspeisen
Starters
Mariniertes Kalb/ Kopfsalat / Pfifferlinge / Parmesan
Veal / chanterelles, lettuce, parmesan
Lachs / Gurke / Avokado / Rettich
Salmon / cucumber, avocado, raddish
Zwischengericht
Entremet
Meeresfrüchteravioli / Tomate / Basilikum
Sea food ravioli, tomato, basil
Hauptgerichte
Main dishes
Atlantik Rotbarsch / Fenchel / Safran / Paprika
Redfish / fennel, saffron, pepper
Lammrücken / Erbse / grüner Spargel / kleines Ragout
Saddle of lamb / pea, green asparagus, ragout
Greetings from the Chef
Dessert
Desserts
Himbeere / Pfirsich / Sauerampfer / Vanille
Raspberry / peach, vanilla, sorrel
Schwarzwälder Kirsch / Schokolade / Kirschwasser / Sorbet
Black Forest Cherry / chocolate, kirschwasser, sherbet
oder
or
Käse
cheese
Greetings from the Chef
The Wines
Mathias Schreiber: Our wine list now comprises more than 250 entries, including numerous big names, but also valuable insider secrets, thanks not least to the current generation of German winemakers.
We chose the following 6 wines, all German except for the last bottle. Le Reysse, however, is German-owned.
Weinsinn is Moving
Most likely, this was my last dinner at the Weinsinn at its current location. Weinsinn is closing its doors at its current location at the end of September and will reopen a few weeks later in the Weserstrasse, close to the Willy Brandt Platz. The 27 written on a blackboard at the bar of the Weinsinn at the night we were there indicated the number of remaining evenings left at the current location.
schiller-wine: Related Postings
Schiller's Favorite Wine Bars in Frankfurt, Germany
Heads up for the 2017 Tours - to Germany and France - by ombiasy WineTours
Burgundy (and Champagne) 2016 Tour by ombiasy WineTours: From Lyon to Reims - Wine, Food, Culture and History
Germany-East Tour 2017 by ombiasy WineTours: Wine, Art, Culture and History
Salon Tasting at Schiller's Home: Sparkling Wines of the World
Salon Tasting at Schiller‘s Home: Domaine Weinbach, Alsace, Vintage 2014 (2017)
Lunch and Beaujolais at Weinsinn in Frankfurt am Main, Germany
Sauvignon Blanc in Austria – A Comparative Tasting with Falstaff's Peter Moser at Weinsinn in Frankfurt, Germany
Schiller's Favorite Wine Bars in Frankfurt, Germany
Schiller's Favorite Apple Wine Taverns in Frankfurt am Main, Germany
Schiller's Favorites: Frankfurt Apple Wine Taverns that Make their own Apple Wine - Frankfurter Apfelweinlokale die noch selbst Keltern, Germany
The Best Restaurants in the Greater Frankfurt am Main Region, Germany
Wine in Frankfurt am Main? - Weingut der Stadt Frankfurt, Germany